← Back to the book

Free sample · Part I: The Paperwork

Chapter 2: The Cita Previa Hunger Games

From Spain Is Broken… And I'm Never Leaving: Confessions of a Reluctantly Happy Expat by David Stewart

Cartoon of a tired man in a headband staring at his phone at night, which says “No hay citas disponibles,” while an owl watches from the window.
Illustration by M.W. Khoirul

At some point in the last two decades, someone in the Spanish government had an idea: Instead of waiting in line, they should make an appointment online. A cita previa. Prior appointment. Modern. Efficient. Dignified.

It was a good idea. I want to give credit. The execution has produced one of the great absurdist systems of our time, and I say that as someone who has read Kafka and found him a little on-the-nose.

Here is how you get a cita previa. You go to the website. You authenticate with a secret app called Cl@ve (more about this later). You pick your province. The website was created in 2009 and has been updated twice, both times to make it worse. You select the procedure from a dropdown list of forty-one procedures, of which yours is either number 6 or number 29; the difference between 6 and 29 will not be explained, and choosing wrong means you will discover it in eight weeks while standing in a building. You enter your document number. You enter it again because the field silently rejected the letter.

You go on to solve a CAPTCHA. You solve a second CAPTCHA that doesn't exist and is a psychological instrument. Then the screen says: No hay citas disponibles. No appointments available. Not “no appointments available until March,” not “next available: 14 April,” none. The concept of an available appointment doesn't currently exist in the observable universe. Try again later. Later is not defined. What happens next is that you become a scientist. You come up with ideas. New appointments drop at midnight; no, at 8 a.m.; no, they’re constantly coming in and out as people cancel, so you want to be constantly checking on them during business hours, like a day trader with lower returns.

I came across a well-known expat blog that said appointment slots are released at 10 p.m. on Wednesdays; another person on that same blog mentioned that the trick is to select a different province and then change back. A third person suggested using Chrome in incognito mode since the site remembers you and penalizes you for being loyal. You could attempt all of these methods. You'll do this for weeks and set an alarm for 11:58 p.m., then lie in bed with your phone, checking the government website in the dark, like a man waiting for a text from someone who won't send one.

And then, one afternoon, you will get one. An appointment. It is real. It exists. It is in a town ninety minutes away, in five weeks, at 9:20 a.m. You will take it instantly, with your heart going, before someone else takes it. You will feel an adrenal rush of pure animal triumph that is totally beyond the scope of what has happened, which is that a government has agreed to look at you.

I actually had to hire a concierge a few times to keep an eye on when the citas show up, because hey, you gotta sleep sometime too. And if a concierge can’t find one, well, I can tell you about the appointment mafias because otherwise you won’t believe me later. The appointments are free. Obviously, they’re free; there just aren’t any. So an ecosystem developed: bots that constantly scrape the site, snag every appointment as soon as it appears, and then resell it. There are WhatsApp numbers. There are Telegram channels. Some men will sell you a free government appointment for thirty, fifty, a hundred euros, depending on the office and the season, and the thing is, they deliver. The service works. It has a customer satisfaction rate that the underlying government service could not dream of.

Spain has, through pure institutional inertia, accidentally privatized the queue. A functioning secondary market now exists for the right to stand in front of a public servant. Economists should be studying this. Instead, we are all just in a Telegram group called something like CITAS EXTRANJERÍA BCN, waiting for a man named Amir to change our lives. I have never paid one of them. I want that on the record—just concierge was enough, thank God. I have considered it, at 1:40 in the morning, on refresh number four hundred, seriously.

Here’s the turn, and it’s the important one, so I’m going to be sincere for four paragraphs, and then we will go back to jokes. The cita previa system showed me something I could not have learned in a country that worked: You cannot do this alone. Not “it’s harder alone.” You literally can’t fix it. Someone with a good heart and a folder can’t solve the system. It was only a matter of luck that the only people I know who have managed Spanish administration did it because somebody helped them. So you ask the woman in the corner bar, because you see her every morning. She doesn’t know, but her brother-in-law did this exact procedure last year, and she’ll ask him. She asks him. He calls you. He tells you for 11 minutes what it is. He gives you his number in case you get stuck. You have never met this man. You will never meet this man. He is now, in a real sense, your guy. That's why Spanish social life is what it is. It’s not a mystery of national character. It’s infrastructure. Human relationships are load-bearing in a country without recognized channels; they are the actual mechanism by which things happen.

A person here has a lifetime-accumulated network of cousins and neighbors and the guy from the gym, and that network isn’t sentimentality; it’s utilities. It’s how you get a plumber, a doctor’s appointment, a job, and a cita previa for extranjería. When you finally get inside the building, five weeks later, ninety minutes from home, the appointment takes four minutes, if your papers are in order (are they? You better hope so). Four minutes. You wait five weeks for four minutes, and after you have done so, you’ll stand outside in the sun holding a stamped paper, feeling a little religious, and after that you’ll go home, and it will be 10:15 in the morning, and you’ll think: honestly? Not the worst Tuesday.

That's one chapter. There are thirty-one more, and thirty-three reasons to stay.